Cracking stucco on a century-old house is rarely just a cosmetic issue. On this 1920s home, the cracks were a signal that the wood behind them had been failing quietly for years, and the owners were also dealing with cold rooms in winter and black ants showing up indoors.
The house is one of only a handful of 1920s-era homes on its block, with most neighboring houses built decades later. Original plank sheathing, inadequate blown-in insulation, and aging stucco left the walls with little real protection against Minnesota winters. Working across the Twin Cities metro from our base in White Bear Lake, MN, we planned the project as a full exterior rebuild rather than a surface repair, with the work completed in a single 30-day stretch.
Key Takeaways
- THE CHALLENGEFailing stucco hid widespread wood rot, missing insulation, and ant nests that could not be seen until demo began.
- THE INSTALLWe removed the stucco, re-sheathed roughly 75% of the house in 4x8 plywood, added two layers of insulation, and installed LP SmartSide siding with new Marvin Essential windows.
- THE RESULTA tighter, warmer, code-compliant exterior with a service life measured in decades rather than years.
Replacing the windows alone would have left the real problem buried behind the walls. Because the stucco was cracking for a reason, we recommended pulling it off completely so the sheathing could be inspected, repaired, and brought back up to current building standards. That decision turned a window job into a full exterior rebuild, and it is the same call we would make on any customer's home.
Project Summary
| Client Profile: | Owners of a 1920s single-family home |
| Project Location: | Twin Cities Metro, Minnesota |
| Primary Objective: | Remove failing stucco and rebuild the exterior with new Siding Installation Services that correct the hidden rot and insulation problems. |
| Material Selection: | LP SmartSide siding over new plywood sheathing, paired with Marvin Essential units through our Window Installation Services. |
| Key Outcome: | Whole-house exterior completed in 30 days with roughly 75% of the sheathing replaced and insulation doubled |
Why the Stucco Was Cracking
Our walkthrough showed stucco that was cracking in several places and a front wall that had visibly bowed outward. Cracks like that usually point to movement or moisture behind the surface, so we planned for sheathing repairs before a single panel came off. What the demo uncovered was worse than expected: the wood was rotting in the middle of the walls and across much of the house.
The rot also explained the black ants the owners had been fighting indoors, since the softened wood gave them a place to nest. A pest control company was brought in to start treatment right away so the problem would not follow the new walls. Insulation was another issue, with the old blown-in material falling short of the R-value required by current code and leaving the bowed front wall noticeably cold.
Re-Sheathing, Insulation, and Siding
We stripped the stucco, tore out the old blown-in insulation, and replaced the original wood plank sheathing with 4x8 plywood sheathing across roughly 75% of the house. New batt insulation went into the wall cavities, then an added layer of rigid foam board over the sheathing for extra winter performance, followed by sealing at the seams. We also enlarged the attic vent box, since the attic ran too hot in summer and did not move enough air in winter.
"You don't always understand or know what's under your siding until you actually do the demo and find those hidden damages." - (Callie, Amigo Roofing)
Window selection came down to Marvin and Andersen at matching price points, and the Marvin Essential line won because the sashes slid up and down smoothly instead of feeling loose in the opening. Budget mattered here, so the Essential line delivered the thermal performance and everyday function the owners wanted without pushing the project past its number. Coordinating the window delivery, the sheathing repairs, and the siding install kept the whole exterior moving as one job, the same way we handle White Bear Lake Roofing and exterior projects, and as a Family Owned Contractor the owners stayed involved in every decision along the way.
New plywood sheathing, added insulation, and LP SmartSide siding replaced the home's failing original stucco. A Warmer, Tighter Century Home
Every exterior surface on the house is now new, from the sheathing out. The rotted wood is gone, the ant nests have no place to return to, the walls hold insulation that meets code, and the enlarged attic venting keeps air moving through the seasons. Rooms that used to run cold in January are now wrapped in two layers of insulation instead of settled blown-in material.
The LP SmartSide carries a 50-year warranty on its finish, but the bigger gain is structural. Swapping century-old plank sheathing for full plywood sheets, then doubling the insulation and sealing the envelope, should keep this house sound for generations with routine repainting down the road. Projects like this are a good reminder to budget for unforeseen rot before you open up an older home, because what the demo reveals often sets the real scope.
Before
After Planning a Siding or Window Project?
We work on century homes throughout the Northeast Twin Cities, and we know how often old stucco and tired siding hide rot, pest damage, and insulation that quit decades ago. Our owners manage every project personally, so you get honest findings and clear numbers before anything gets covered back up.
Thinking about siding, windows, or an exterior rebuild for your home near White Bear Lake? Reach out today for a Free Roofing Estimate and we will take a look.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should stucco be replaced with siding on an older White Bear Lake home?
If your stucco is cracking, it is usually responding to a problem behind it rather than simply aging. Removing it lets us inspect the sheathing, correct rot, and rebuild the wall with proper insulation. On this 1920s home, the switch to LP SmartSide siding gave the owners a durable exterior and a chance to bring the walls up to current code.
How long does a full siding and window replacement take?
This whole-house project took 30 days from start to finish. It would have moved faster, but roughly 75% of the home needed new sheathing and new insulation once the stucco came off. Hidden repairs are the most common reason a schedule stretches on a century home.
How long will the new siding and sheathing last?
The LP SmartSide carries a 50-year warranty on its paint finish, and repainting down the road extends the look well beyond that. The plywood sheathing, batt insulation, and rigid foam layer underneath are what really add decades of structural life. Keep an eye on the finish and the sealed seams, and the wall system should serve the house for generations.